Skip to content
Ritholtz Wealth Management logo 10,563 reviews

How to choose between an annuity and a bond ladder for guaranteed retirement income

By Marcus Thompson, CFA | Reviewed by Hiroshi Tanaka, CFP | November 15, 2026

Two women reading a financial magazine over coffee

For a five-year income gap, the annuity vs bond ladder question usually ends in a ladder, and Ritholtz Wealth Management prices both tools in dollars before choosing. The reason is arithmetic: a gap that ends on a known date can be matched dollar for dollar with bonds, while an annuity charges you for a lifetime you may not need to insure.

The question matters more than it seems because the wrong choice shows up in places you are not watching: your Medicare premium, your taxable income in retirement, and what your heirs receive. A product that looks like a paycheck can quietly raise the bill for the one you already have.

This article follows a calendar rather than a sales page. It walks from the last paychecks at 64, through Medicare at 65 and the bridge years, to Social Security at 70 and the required-minimum-distribution age, using a hypothetical retiree named Olga. Every step prices the annuity vs bond ladder decision in dollars, the way an engineer would check a spec sheet.

At 64, the last paychecks are still arriving

Most people arrive at this decision carrying a belief: a guaranteed-income product must be the only way to build a floor under Social Security. The actual rule is simpler and colder. A floor is a gap number, essential bills minus reliable income, and once you write that number down, both tools can be priced without any product pitch.

Financial Planning OverviewKey financial planning considerationsFinancial Planning OverviewAssessmentReview your current financial situation1StrategyDevelop a personalized plan2ImplementationPut your plan into action3MonitoringReview and adjust regularly4Key Areas of Financial PlanningA structured approach helps you stay on trackRitholtz Wealth Management

Olga is 64, single, and retired last month from a career as a software architect, with no mortgage payment to plan around. She has $2.3M in a three-fund portfolio she has managed herself for 25 years, and she plans to claim Social Security at 70. For illustration, those are the numbers we will use throughout. What the paycheck stop actually removed was three things: the salary, the 401(k) contributions it funded, and the discount on employer stock she used to buy through the purchase plan. Only the salary is permanent; the other two had been quietly subsidizing her savings rate.

Notice what did not change: the mortgage line, because there is none, and the bills, which run $3,800 a month. That constancy is what makes a floor analyzable. If your spending swings month to month, run an average first; the tools on this page assume a number you trust.

The belief and the rule

What does each tool actually guarantee?

An immediate annuity guarantees an income stream that stops only at death, but the guarantee is only as good as the issuing insurer's claims-paying ability. State guaranty associations back annuity owners up to coverage caps each state sets on its own, so the two tools are not offering the same guarantee at all.

A Treasury rung held to maturity repays its face value, backed by the full faith of the federal government; sold before maturity, it fetches whatever the market is quoting that day, above or below what you paid.

Why a payout rate is not an interest rate

Price the gap in dollars, not percentages

Here is the subtraction that frames everything else. Olga's essential bills are $3,800 a month. Her projected Social Security check at age 70 is $2,300 a month. The difference is $1,500 a month, or $18,000 a year, for the years between Medicare at 65 and claiming at 70. That $18,000 is the number both tools compete on, not portfolio yield and not a payout rate printed in a brochure.

Her shortcut: multiply the monthly gap by the number of months until the later Social Security claim. If the result is a known, finite number, a ladder can be sized exactly to it. An annuity cannot be sized to a gap that ends. It can only be sized to a life. When the number is finite, buy the finite instrument.

At what age does Medicare pricing take over the withdrawal order?

At 65, the two-year income lookback starts to matter: Medicare premiums for a given year are set by modified adjusted gross income from two years earlier. Spending decisions at 63 and 64 price Medicare at 65 and 66, which is why the bridge has to be built before the paychecks stop.

For 2026, a single filer pays $202.90 a month in Part B premiums up to $109,000 of MAGI, $284.10 from $109,000 to $137,000, and $405.80 up to $171,000. Cross one tier and the premium rises by about $81 a month, roughly $974 for that year.

Which income counts matters here. Treasury interest and annuity payments are federal taxable income, so both feed the tiers. The Part B deductible of $283 is the entry cost before any of this matters, and it arrives in the first month of coverage. If your projected MAGI sits within $20,000 of a tier line, the account placement of the bridge (section 8) decides whether you stay under it. Related reading: how the IRMAA lookback works on our IRMAA planning page.

Callout: Medicare premiums are set by income from two years earlier. 2026 single-filer tiers: $202.90 a month up to $109,000 of MAGI, $284.10 to $137,000. Build the bridge before the lookback year, not during it.

Five rungs beat one check

Buy the first-year rung before the last paycheck, sized to the first year of the gap, and repeat so a rung matures in each bridge year. The point is sequencing: the ladder is funded while W-2 income still exists and a high taxable year absorbs it anyway, not after it stops and every dollar withdrawn pushes your MAGI toward a Medicare tier. Building the TIPS ladder rungs year by year is covered on its own page. Five rungs, one per year from 65 to 69, is the whole structure. No product sale, no surrender schedule, no medical underwriting.

What does an annuity quote have to beat?

Get a real quote at least six months before Medicare starts, convert it to the cost of the same monthly check the ladder provides, and read the free-look window and the death-value terms in the paperwork before signing anything.

The comparison is not annuity versus nothing; it is annuity versus a stack of Treasuries you can price to the dollar on any brokerage screen. If a quote promises $1,500 a month, ask what premium buys it, then ask what $1,500 a month for five years costs in rungs. If the insurer's premium is more than double the ladder, the quote has to be justified by longevity, not by the bridge.

For illustration: Olga's calendar from 64 to 75

For illustration, follow Olga's hypothetical calendar. At 64 she prices the gap: $18,000 a year for five years, ages 65 through 69, a $90,000 bridge. At 65 Medicare begins and the bridge starts paying. At 70 her $2,300 Social Security check arrives and the ladder is finished. At 75 the RMD age applies for anyone born in 1960 or later, and pre-tax balances start paying out regardless of what she wants. Ages 64 to 70 are the only years the two tools are actually competing.

The ladder side: five TIPS rungs of $18,000 each, about $90,000 total, each repaying face value at maturity. Treasury interest is federally taxable but exempt from state tax, and she pays no state income tax anyway. One honest caveat: TIPS held in a taxable account generate phantom income. The CPI adjustment is federally taxable each year even though it is not paid until maturity, so a spike in inflation means owing tax on money never received. Holding the rungs inside a traditional IRA avoids the annual tax, which matters when a tier line sits nearby.

The annuity side: to pay the same $18,000 a year, a single-life quote at an illustrative 6.5% payout requires about $277,000 ($18,000 ÷ 0.065). That is roughly three times the ladder's cost for a bridge that ends at 70. And the payout rate is not a return: part of each payment from a non-IRA immediate annuity is a tax-free return of premium until the premium is recovered, which is why 6.5% does not mean 6.5% interest. Bought inside a traditional IRA instead, every payment is fully taxable 1099-R income stacked on her other withdrawals, pushing her toward the $109,000 tier and lifting her Part B premium from $202.90 to $284.10 a month.

Make the trade-off explicit. The annuity keeps paying if she lives past 90, and that is the only scenario where triple the cost buys something the ladder cannot. That is a longevity bet, not a bridge. Anyone selling it as a bridge is selling the wrong instrument for the stated problem. If Olga's real worry is outliving her money at 92, that is a separate decision with its own math, priced separately. The site's calculator runs this same gap math on your own numbers; start there before taking any quote.

The two tools side by side:

The ladder side

The annuity side

Where the trade-off actually sits

Choosing between an annuity and a bond ladder, using the hypothetical $90,000 five-year bridge example
If this is trueThen lean towardWhy
Gap lasts 5 years or fewerBond ladder$90K of rungs vs about $277K for the same monthly check
Gap could last past the mid-80sSingle-life annuityThe ladder ends; the annuity keeps paying
One spouse is much youngerPrice a joint annuity vs a longer ladderTwo lives lower the payout per dollar
Social Security and a pension cover the billsNeither toolA floor you already have is not worth buying
Money sits in a traditional IRALadder, or annuity in brokerage moneyEvery IRA annuity payment is fully taxable income

The letter that arrives in December

A retiree put a $250,000 SPIA inside a traditional IRA, then opened the December Social Security letter showing a $284.10 premium instead of $202.90. The 1099-R had reported every annuity payment as ordinary income, his MAGI crossed $109,000, and the tier cost $974.40 for the year. Nobody warned him, because the insurance agent was not modeling his withdrawals from the IRA alongside the new payments. The mistake was discovered by the government's own mail, twelve months after it was made.

The fix is placement. Buy annuities with brokerage money, where part of each payment is a tax-free return of premium until the premium is recovered, or keep bridge money in rungs whose interest stays below the tier. And check the projected MAGI line against $109,000 before any purchase, not after. Account placement decides the tax bill as much as the product choice does. Related: a 401(k) rollover to an IRA changes which dollars are pre-tax, so it belongs in this same review.

How does the answer shift for a couple or a smaller balance?

For a married couple, a joint-and-survivor annuity pays less per dollar because it covers two lives, so the premium needed for the same gap grows again. For illustration, Ramon and Yolanda, hypothetical, are 61 and 59 and married. Their essential bills exceed their combined reliable income by $2,000 a month, and his Social Security starts at 67, six years away.

That is a $24,000-a-year, $144,000 bridge. Five to six TIPS rungs of about $24,000 each cover it, with Treasury interest state-exempt. A joint-and-survivor annuity at an illustrative 5.8% payout would need about $414,000 ($24,000 ÷ 0.058) to pay the same amount for two lives, nearly triple the ladder's cost, and payments from their pre-tax IRAs would count toward the $218,000 joint first IRMAA tier. For a couple whose bridge ends at his claiming date, the ladder wins on cost. Waiting past full retirement age to claim is its own decision, covered on the Social Security claiming page.

Two other shifts. If Social Security plus a small pension already covers essential bills, neither tool earns its keep; the honest answer is no purchase. Buying a floor you already own just moves assets and adds paperwork. And if retirement starts later, say at 70, the bridge stretches and the annuity becomes more competitive, because the ladder would need more rungs at a life stage when the money may be needed for care instead.

Bringing an adult child into the decision

Put the two quotes and the ladder schedule on a single page and let the child ask the inheritance question first. The paperwork answers it: unspent ladder rungs pass to heirs and repay face value at maturity, while a single-life annuity typically leaves nothing at death. Handing a parent the comparison sheet beats defending the purchase in the abstract. If the child asks why the annuity costs three times as much, that is the longevity question, and it deserves the straight answer from section 7.

Your questions about annuity vs bond ladder, answered

What happens if I need a large lump sum for care and no rung has matured?

A rung sold early fetches the current market price, which can be lower than face value if rates have risen. You would sell the rung maturing soonest, taking the smallest price risk, and the loss is usually modest. An annuity premium, by contrast, is locked away: a $277,000 single-life contract typically cannot be unwound for care costs at all.

How soon before Medicare starts should the first rungs be in place?

Buy the first-year rung before your last paycheck, so the bridge is funded before the MAGI year that the Medicare lookback reads. Premiums for the year you turn 65 are set by income from two years earlier, so purchases made at 63 with salary income still arriving cost you nothing at the tier line.

Our daughter asks: what does she inherit from each choice?

Unspent ladder rungs pass to heirs and repay face value at maturity; the Treasury obligation does not disappear when the owner does. A single-life immediate annuity typically leaves nothing at death, though some contracts offer a period-certain option that continues payments for a set term in exchange for a lower monthly check.

Does Treasury interest count toward the Medicare income tiers?

Yes. Treasury interest is federally taxable income and feeds the modified adjusted gross income figure used to set Part B premiums, though it is exempt from state income tax. A $90,000 ladder throws off only a few thousand in interest each year and rarely moves a tier by itself; a $277,000 annuity premium can.

Can the ladder live inside my IRA instead of the brokerage account?

Yes, and inside a traditional IRA the TIPS phantom income is not taxed annually, unlike in a taxable account. The trade-off is that IRA withdrawals later count as ordinary income toward the Medicare tiers, so run the projected MAGI line against $109,000 single or $218,000 joint before deciding where the rungs sit.

Ritholtz Wealth Management's first pass over the accounts

Ritholtz Wealth Management would start by listing which dollars are pre-tax, because that decides whether annuity payments or ladder interest would cross the $109,000 single-filer tier in a given year. It would then map each bridge year against the tier thresholds and read the beneficiary designations, since a ladder's unspent rungs and an annuity's death value are not the same thing for heirs. Both take an afternoon; neither requires buying anything first.

A ladder can be sized to a gap that ends. An annuity can only be sized to a life.

Sources

This article provides general information only and is not individualized investment, tax or legal advice. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Talk to a qualified professional about your specific situation before making any financial moves.

Request information