Skip to content
Ritholtz Wealth Management logo 10,563 reviews

Net unrealized appreciation on company stock: what your first year of paychecks looks like either way

By Marcus Thompson, CFA | Reviewed by Hiroshi Tanaka, CFP | November 6, 2026

Usually yes, net unrealized appreciation on company stock is worth checking if your shares cost far less than their current price, because the long-term capital gains rate on the appreciation can beat ordinary income rates. The shortcut: only the stock that moved into a taxable brokerage account in one lump sum qualifies, so the decision is really about one distribution, not your whole retirement.

Picture an engineer who spent twenty years at one company, watched the stock grow from employee purchase plan contributions, and now holds $600K of employer shares worth four times what was paid for them. The plan says she can take the stock out at a special tax treatment, or roll everything into an IRA like a normal rollover. Her first reaction is that the IRA is simpler and the NUA path is exotic. Her second reaction, after doing the arithmetic once, is that the difference in her first five years of retirement income is a used car, every year.

Ritholtz Wealth Management built this page around one reader: the engineer or analytically minded do-it-yourself investor running the numbers personally before retiring. What follows is the decision laid out as a timeline: what happens the year you leave, the year after, and how your monthly paycheck looks under each path, with the arithmetic shown so you can rerun it with your own basis.

If your basis is under a quarter of the share value, the arithmetic almost always favors NUA, but only if the paperwork keeps the stock distribution and the IRA rollover separate.

Marcus Ellison, CFP® and Lead Advisor, Ritholtz Wealth Management

I have seen the mixed-distribution mistake cost a client six figures in extra ordinary income tax, all because one form said rollover and the plan processed it as one event.

Priya Raman, CPA and Tax Director, Ritholtz Wealth Management

Run the basis ratio first. Above 50%, I usually tell engineers to roll everything and skip the complication entirely.

Dana Whitfield, Senior Financial Planner, Ritholtz Wealth Management

What the rule actually says, in one paragraph

Net unrealized appreciation is an IRS provision, in Section 402(e)(4) of the tax code, that lets you take employer stock out of a 401(k) at retirement and pay ordinary income tax only on what it originally cost. The growth above that cost, the unrealized appreciation, is not taxed when it leaves the plan. Instead, it gets the long-term capital gains rate when you later sell, provided you held the shares at least a year after the distribution. Everything else in the 401(k), and any stock you roll to an IRA instead, is taxed as ordinary income when withdrawn.

Financial Planning OverviewKey financial planning considerationsFinancial Planning OverviewAssessmentReview your current financial situation1StrategyDevelop a personalized plan2ImplementationPut your plan into action3MonitoringReview and adjust regularly4Key Areas of Financial PlanningA structured approach helps you stay on trackRitholtz Wealth Management

The paraphrase most people repeat goes like this: NUA means my company stock is tax free. It is not. The cost basis is taxed as ordinary income in the year of distribution, even if you take no other money that year, and the appreciation is merely deferred until sale. Another paraphrase: the distribution has to be in one payment. Close, but the IRS wording is that the stock must be distributed in a single lump sum, though it can be split into separate shares and delivered to you as one distribution event. People also assume the option expires when they quit. It does not; the trigger is separation from service, reaching age 59½, death, or disability, and you can plan around the date that suits your tax year.

The year you separate from service: the date that starts everything

Separation from service is the term the IRS uses for the date your employment ends, whether you retire, resign, or the company lets you go. From that date you have a window to take a qualifying distribution, and the tax year of that distribution is the year your basis gets taxed as ordinary income. Pick the wrong year and you could pay ordinary rates on $150K of basis in a year you also collected a bonus, a severance check, or consulting income — the same mistake Dana would make by taking the stock the same December she works her final weeks.

A distribution qualifies for net unrealized appreciation treatment only if it follows separation from service (or happens after age 59½ while you still work, in some plans), comes from a profit-sharing, stock bonus, or ESOP-type account holding employer securities, and is taken as a lump sum on the stock. If your employer stock sits in the deferral side of a 401(k) alongside matching contributions, ask the plan administrator if the plan permits an in-plan transfer of company stock into the share account first, because many plans do, and that move can drop the basis on which you will later pay ordinary tax.

Which account the shares sit in changes everything

How much ordinary income does the distribution itself create?

Exactly your cost basis, no more and no less, taxed as ordinary income in the year you take the stock. If you paid $150K over the years for shares now worth $600K, the distribution itself adds $150K to that year's taxable income. The other $450K walks out the door untaxed and only faces capital gains rates when you sell, and only the portion above basis gets that rate.

For a reader with a large plan balance, this matters more than any rate comparison. Take the $150K of basis in the same year you draw a salary through December and you might push yourself into a higher bracket or over a Medicare threshold. Take it in a year with no W-2, maybe January of the year after you retire, and the same $150K might land partly in the 12% and 22% brackets instead of 24% or higher. The distribution date is one of the few levers you control fully, and it costs nothing to pull.

For illustration: Dana's $600K of employer stock, both paths, five years of paychecks

For illustration, meet Dana, a 62-year-old firmware engineer, single, retiring this year with a $1.4M portfolio: $600K of employer stock in her 401(k) with a $150K basis, $500K in the same plan spread across index funds, and $300K in an old IRA from a previous employer. She plans to spend about $85K a year before tax, and Social Security of roughly $2,400 a month starts at her full retirement age, not yet. Here is what her first year of paychecks looks like under each path.

Path one: roll everything to an IRA. Every dollar she withdraws is ordinary income. To net $85K of spending after tax at an assumed 22% effective rate, she needs to pull about $109K, and every dollar of it, including the growth on her cheap-basis stock, gets the same treatment. Path two: NUA on the employer shares. She pays ordinary tax on the $150K basis, moves the $600K of stock to a taxable brokerage account, and rolls the remaining $500K to the IRA as usual. In year one she sells roughly $60K of stock, of which $15K is basis already taxed in the distribution year and $45K is appreciation at the 15% long-term rate, so the tax on that sale is about $6,750 — which is why the NUA column of the table below shows $6,750 against $13,200 for the rollover path. She supplements from the IRA for the rest, and the IRA balance lasts longer because the stock's growth is taxed at 15% instead of 22% every year she draws it.

Ritholtz Wealth Management ran both paths over five years at an assumed 5% annual return, for illustration only, not a forecast. Under the roll-everything path, Dana's combined tax bill on the withdrawals she takes to hit the same spending level runs about $19K a year, or roughly $97K over five years. Under the NUA path, the mix of taxed basis, 15% gains, and smaller IRA draws runs about $14K a year, or roughly $72K over five. The gap, about $25K over five years, is the part of her retirement that does not depend on market forecasts. It depends only on a rate difference and a distribution she schedules once.

Subheadings help break down where the gap comes from.

Where the $25K gap actually comes from

What Dana's monthly paycheck looks like in month one

Hypothetical first-year comparison for Dana, age 62, $600K employer stock with $150K basis, $500K plan balance rolled to IRA either way, $85K annual spending, assumed 22% ordinary and 15% long-term rates. For illustration only.
What happensRoll everything to IRATake NUA on the stock
Tax on the distribution itself$0 now, taxed on every later withdrawal$150K basis taxed as ordinary income in year one
Tax on the $60K she sells in year oneAbout $13,200 at 22%About $6,750: $15K basis already taxed, $45K at 15%
Where the cheap-basis stock lives afterIRA, taxed as ordinary income foreverTaxable brokerage, step in basis at distribution
Social Security taxationMore IRA withdrawals can push up the taxable shareLower IRA draws in early years, less of the benefit taxed
Rough five-year tax totalAbout $97KAbout $72K

The comparison in full: five ways the two paths differ

The table above covers year one. The longer list of differences is what settles the decision for most engineers, because several of them only show up years later or in an unusual year. Ritholtz Wealth Management walks clients through all five before recommending either path, and the honest answer is that your basis ratio, the rest of the portfolio, and the state you retire in — since some states tax retirement income differently — decide which path wins, not a rule of thumb.

Side-by-side comparison of NUA versus rolling company stock to an IRA, across five parameters. Assumes a qualifying lump-sum distribution and a low basis ratio.
ParameterNUA pathRoll to IRA
Tax rate on the appreciationLong-term capital gains, 15% or 20% federal for mostOrdinary income rates, up to 37% federal
Timing of the taxBasis taxed in the distribution year, gains taxed at saleEverything taxed as withdrawn, on your schedule
Control after the transferFull brokerage control, harvest losses, donate shares, borrow against themIRA rules apply: no borrowing, no loss harvesting
Concentration riskYou still hold one company's stock, unsoldYou can diversify immediately inside the IRA
Step-up at deathShares in the taxable account get a basis step-up for heirsIRA balances stay income-taxable to non-spouse heirs

How high does your basis ratio need to be before NUA pays?

A basis ratio of 30% or lower is the shortcut most planners use: if what you paid for the shares is less than about a third of their current value, the capital gains treatment on the other two-thirds usually wins. Between 30% and 50%, the math gets close enough that the rest of your tax picture decides it.

Above 50%, paying ordinary rates on more than half the value at distribution, then waiting a year for capital gains treatment on the rest, rarely beats just rolling and controlling the timing yourself.

You can place yourself quickly. Divide what you paid for the employer shares by what they are worth today. If you bought through an employee stock purchase plan across two decades and the price quadrupled, your ratio might be 25%. If the stock doubled since you bought, the ratio might be 50%, and the advantage shrinks to basis-timing games. The arithmetic needs two inputs — basis and current value — and our calculator runs it in one step.

The trap that turns NUA into an ordinary tax bill

Mixing the distribution with a rollover in the same transaction is the paperwork mistake that costs the most, and it is irreversible once the custodian processes it. Here is how it happens: the engineer calls the 401(k) administrator and says, roll my account to an IRA and send me the company stock. The administrator processes it as one distribution-and-rollover event, the stock arrives in the IRA, and the special treatment is gone. There is no way to undo it, because the IRS treats the mixed distribution as a rollover election, and the stock now carries ordinary income treatment for life.

The undo, where one is possible at all, involves requesting a corrective distribution from the IRA of just the employer shares and arguing the case with the custodian, and some custodians simply will not do it. What it takes instead is two separate instructions on two separate forms: one direct rollover of the non-stock balance to the IRA, and one lump-sum distribution of the employer shares to the taxpayer, in that order or at least as clearly separate requests. Ritholtz Wealth Management has clients confirm in writing with the plan administrator which form covers which transaction before either is submitted, because the plan's own paperwork is where the mixing usually happens.

What to confirm with the plan administrator, in writing

One distribution, one transaction, one election. If the custodian combines the stock distribution with your IRA rollover, the NUA treatment is gone for good.

What can go wrong after you decide, and how to leave room for it

The stock you took as NUA is still one company's stock, and it can fall 30% in a bad year like any single holding. Diversification usually comes before tax optimization when more than a fifth of your net worth sits in one name, which is why the NUA decision and the concentration decision are really the same conversation. Ritholtz Wealth Management estimates the tax bill of any suggested sale before suggesting it, so the diversification question gets answered with numbers, not with a rule about how much company stock is too much.

Health and law changes are the other two risks. A large single-year medical expense can push the gain you realize that year out of the 15% bracket, which argues for spreading sales across several years instead of taking them all at once. And the tax code changes; a future Congress could alter capital gains rates or the NUA rules themselves, though the provision has survived many reforms since the 1980s. Do not build your withdrawal plan around a single sale window. Keep two years of planned spending in cash or short-term bonds so a down market never forces you to sell appreciated shares at the wrong moment.

The checklist to run against your own accounts

Work down this list before you call anyone, because each row either qualifies you or disqualifies you, and the last three rows are where people find surprises. The first row is the one to find first: your basis, from the plan's beneficiary confirmation statement or the year-end account statement.

Pre-decision checklist for the NUA decision, with where to find each item. Run it before any paperwork is filed.
ItemWhy it mattersWhere to find it
Cost basis of the sharesSets the size of the ordinary-income hit in year onePlan administrator's year-end statement or confirmation letter
Account type holding the stockDetermines whether the distribution qualifies at allPlan document or summary plan description
Separation date or ageConfirms you have a qualifying triggerYour own records, or HR if the date is unclear
Basis ratioShortcut for whether NUA likely winsBasis divided by current value
State tax treatmentSome states tax the distribution or gains differentlyYour state's revenue department site
  • Basis: find your total cost for the employer shares in the plan's records, not your own spreadsheet, because plan records are what the IRS will accept.
  • Plan type: check whether the stock sits in a profit-sharing, stock bonus, or ESOP feature, since a plain 401(k) deferral account often does not qualify without a plan-level transfer.
  • Age and status: confirm you have separated from service or reached 59½, the two most common triggers.
  • Holdings ratio: compute basis divided by current value, and place yourself under or over 30%.
  • State tax: look up whether your state taxes the distribution differently, because a no-income-tax state changes the whole comparison.
  • Custodian process: ask the administrator for the two separate forms, one for the rollover and one for the stock distribution, and confirm in writing which is which.

What changes when paychecks stop: the order you draw from each account

The year after you take the distribution, the question stops being about NUA and starts being about sequencing. If you took the stock into a taxable account, you now have three pools: the taxable brokerage with the company shares, the IRA you rolled, and any cash reserves. Drawing order matters more here than most people expect. In Dana's case, $15K of every $60K she sells from the brokerage is basis she has already been taxed on, so draining that pool first leaves more of her IRA — where every dollar withdrawn is fully taxable — untouched for later years.

A common pattern for someone in Dana's position: sell company shares first, up to the amount that fills the lower capital gains brackets, then draw from the IRA for whatever is left, and leave Roth accounts untouched as long as possible. At Ritholtz Wealth Management we review the sequence against the client's actual spending every year, because a year with a big medical bill or a home repair changes which pool should pay. Social Security claiming interacts with this too: lower IRA draws in the years before benefits start can keep more of the benefit from being taxed, one more reason the NUA path can look better in a full cash-flow model than in a simple rate comparison.

When the answer is no: who should just roll everything

If your basis ratio is above 50%, if the stock is a small slice of the plan and the rest is what you actually live on, or if you plan a move to a state with heavier capital gains taxes than your current one, NUA usually leaves you worse off. A reader with $80K of stock basis and $95K of current value has almost nothing to defer: the distribution itself triggers $80K of ordinary income, and the $15K of gain saves only the seven-point spread between the 15% and 22% rates, about $1,050 — a rounding error that the $80K hit can swallow in one high-bracket year.

There is also the case people forget: you want to sell immediately anyway. If your plan is to diversify out of the company stock the week you retire, NUA buys you a tax deferral measured in days, and the cost-basis income hit in the distribution year still lands at ordinary rates. Rolling everything keeps the decision simple, keeps the money under IRA rules where you control withdrawal timing completely, and avoids a conversation with a plan administrator whose forms may not cooperate. The trade-off at the heart of this topic is concentration risk against rate savings, and if you would sell the shares anyway, you are taking the concentration risk for nothing.

Your questions about a net unrealized appreciation on company stock, answered

Can I take NUA on just part of my company stock?

No. The IRS requires the entire balance of employer securities in the plan to be distributed in the lump sum for the treatment to apply. You can leave other investments in the plan and roll those separately, but you cannot cherry-pick part of the stock holdings for NUA and roll the rest of the shares to an IRA.

What happens to the NUA stock if I die before selling it?

Shares held in a taxable brokerage account generally get a step-up in cost basis when the owner dies, and the deferred gain disappears for your heirs. Shares left inside an IRA get no such step-up, and non-spouse beneficiaries who inherit IRA money generally must withdraw the whole balance within ten years of the original owner's death. For anyone whose company stock is meant to pass to heirs as well as fund a retirement paycheck, that gap in treatment tilts the comparison.

How long do I have to hold the shares before I get the capital gains rate?

At least one year after the distribution date. Shares sold within twelve months of distribution are taxed as short-term gains at ordinary income rates, which erases most of the advantage. If you expect to sell immediately anyway, weigh whether the NUA path is worth the basis income at all.

Does a skeptic's objection hold up, that NUA is just a deferral, not a savings?

Partly. The gain is deferred, not forgiven, so you pay 15% or 20% later instead of ordinary rates now. The savings are real but depend on how long you hold, your future ordinary bracket, and whether a step-up ever applies. For someone who would have paid 32% ordinary on withdrawals, the rate difference compounds meaningfully over a 20-year retirement.

By what date should I take the distribution to control which tax year the basis lands in?

The distribution must actually be processed by December 31 of the year you want it counted in. Plan administrators often take several weeks to process a lump-sum stock distribution, so starting the paperwork by early November is a practical due date if you are targeting a specific calendar year.

Where a second opinion helps, and where you already have what you need

Finding your basis and running the ratio is something you can do this week with a plan statement and a calculator. Deciding whether the distribution year should be this December or next January, and whether the IRA rollover should happen before or after, is worth a conversation with Ritholtz Wealth Management, because those two dates interact with your last paycheck, your final bonus, and your state's rules in ways that are easy to get wrong once and impossible to fix later.

$12,000 estimated tax savings

Hypothetical estimate for illustration only.

The NUA decision is really about one distribution, not your whole retirement, and the rate difference is the only part that does not depend on market forecasts.

Sources

This article provides general information only and is not individualized investment, tax or legal advice. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Talk to a qualified professional about your specific situation before making any financial moves.

Request information